California State University System
UPDATE: InterVarsity is Back on Campus at CSU
June 19, 2015: CSU has agreed to allow InterVarsity's 23 chapters to once again become recognized student organizations on the 19 CSU campuses where they are active.
“Following substantive and cordial conversations, CSU has clarified the intent and reach of Executive Order 1068," said InterVarsity president Jim Lundgren. “As a result, we are confident we can choose leaders who are qualified to InterVarsity's witnessing communities throughout the Cal State system."
“In a time where much of the public discourse is polarized, InterVarsity and CSU remained engaged, honest and respectful throughout the negotiations," he added. "While we are grateful to have resolved the issue with CSU, InterVarsity continues to believe that all comers policies will result in the exclusion, rather than inclusion, of diverse students from campus.”
More information can be found in the news release posted on InterVarsity's website and in the links below to news coverage of the resolution.
BACKGROUND:
In 2011, shortly before retiring, the chancellor of the California State University system issued a new policy that requires recognized student groups to accept any student as a potential leader. InterVarsity's chapter leaders are required to affirm InterVarsity's Doctrinal Basis. While we applaud inclusivity, we believe that faith-based communities like ours can only be led by people who clearly affirm historic Christian doctrine.
In August 2013, the new chancellor, Timothy White, granted religious groups a one-year exemption for the 2013-14 school year. The exemption was not renewed for the 2014-2015 school year, which meant all 23 of the CSU InterVarsity chapters operated without the benefits of official recognition.
The response to the policy from various media was overwhelmingly negative toward the policy and in support of InterVarsity's position, as represented by the following links.
CSU/InterVarsity Media Coverage - Resolution
- Christianity Today; June 19, 2015
- World magazine; June 19, 2015
- Newsmax; June 19, 2015
- TheBlaze; June 20, 2015
- Faith Radio network - Austin Hill in the Morning; June 22, 2015
- Christian Post; June 22, 2015
- Mission Network News; June 23, 2015
- Evangelical Focus (Spanish Evangelical Alliance); June 23, 2015
- Deseret News; June 24, 2015
- World magazine; June 26, 2015
- CBN News; July 7, 2015
- Sonoma State Star; August 31, 2015
CSU/InterVarsity Media Coverage - Dispute
NEWSPAPERS/NEWS
- Colleges and Evangelicals Collide on Bias Policy - Michael Paulson, New York Times; June 10, 2014
- Christian Group Sanctioned at Two Dozen Campuses - Religion News Service; September 8, 2014
- CSU Bans Campus Christian Group - CalCoastNews.com; September 10, 2014
- Cal State University Strips Official Status from InterVarsity Christian Fellowship - Long Beach Press Telegram; September 16, 2014
- Christian Group at Sonona State Runs Afoul of Anti-Discrimination Policy - Press Democrat; September 22, 2014
- Christian Group Fights for Identity Against Cal State Policy - Los Angeles Times; October 24, 2014
- Christian Group No Longer Recognized by CSUCI - Ventura County Star; November 9, 2014
NEWSPAPERS/EDITORIALS & COLUMNS
- Orange County Register editorial: A University Policy Beyond Belief - September 12, 2014
- Deseret News editorial: Some Universities Targeting Faith-Based Groups - September 14, 2014
- A Campus Crusade Against the Constitution - Wall Street Journal/Harvey Silverglate; September 18, 2014
- A Just Tool is Taken to Unject Extreme at SSU - Press Democrat; September 25, 2014
- Welcome to College, Where Religious Freedom Goes to Die - Religious Freedom Center/Charles Haynes;
- Hays (KS) Post - September 25, 2014
- Monroe (LA) News Star - September 25, 2014
- Pottstown (PA) Mercury - September 26, 2014
- Pittsburg (KS) Morning Sun - September 27, 2014
- Pocono (PA) Record - September 27, 2014
- Yuma (CA) Sun - September 28, 2014
- Columbia (TN) Daily Herald - September 28, 2014
- Green Bay (WI) Press Gazette - September 29, 2014
- Baxter (AR) Bulletin - September 30, 2014
- Salinas (CA) Californian - October 1, 2014
- Livingston (MI) Daily - October 2, 2014
- Fond du Lac (WI) Reporter - October 2, 2014
- Palm Springs (CA) Desert Sun - October 4, 2014
- Alexandria (LA) Town Talk - October 5, 2014
- CSU's message: Those of Faith Need Not Apply - Press Democrat, October 5, 2014
- Legalized Discrimination Against Campus Christians - Post Independent/James Kellogg; October 20, 2014
- Christians Should Lead Christians - USA Today; November 10, 2014
- WJXXTV - Jacksonville FL; November 10, 2014
- Montgomery Advertiser - Montgomery AL; November 10, 2014
- KGW.com - Portland OR; November 10, 2014
- Press & Sun-Bulletin - Binghamton NY; November 10, 2014
- KREM2 - Spokane WA; November 10, 2014
- The Daily Northwestern - Oshkosh WI; November 10, 2014
- Cincinnati Enquirer - Cincinnati OH; November 10, 2014
- Hattiesburg American - Hattiesburg MS; November 10, 2014
- Times Herald - Port Huron, MI; November 10, 2014
- The Washington Post - Washington DC; November 13, 2014
- Sojourners - Washington DC; November 13, 2014
- Reporter - Lutheran Church Missouri Synod; November 17, 2014
- Pacific Daily News - Hagatna, Guam; November 20, 2014
- Thugs and Free Expression - Matthew Raley/Chico ER Lifestyle; January 30, 2015
- First Amendment under attack - William Jeynes/Orange County Register; February 3, 2015
- Bill targets CSU's 'Believe it or Not' edict - Steven Greenhut/San Diego Union-Tribune; February 27, 2015
- UCLA debate raises questions of discrimination against believers - Adele Keim/San Francisco Chronicle;
March 15, 2015
CAMPUS NEWSPAPERS
- Club equality; a discrimination of its own - CSU Northridge Sunday; March 3, 2013
- Religious organization on the chopping block - Sonoma State Star; August 26, 2014
- When clubbing out goes wrong - editorial, Sonoma State Star; August 27, 2014
- Uncertainty for Christian Club - CSU Fullerton Daily Titan; September 16, 2014
- Cal State retracts recognition of InterVarsity on all 23 campuses - USA Today/Campus; September 18, 2014
- Club Persecuted by CSUs - The Daily Aztec; September 22, 2014
- Christian Club Sanctioned by CSU System - Golden Gate Express; September 27, 2014
- CSU Disassociates InterVarsity from Campuses - Mustang News; September 29, 2014
- Discrimination Consternation: State Policy Creates Issues for Some Cal Poly Clubs - New Times; October 2, 2014
- CSU's derecognition of Christian Club Unfair - Mustang News; October 12, 2014
- Religious Rights, Also Important - Arizona Daily Wildcat; October 13, 2014
- Cru and InterVarsity formally de-recognized as Cal Poly student organizations -
Faculty Commons SLO - October 20, 2014 - InterVarsity Working Toward Representation - Sonoma State Star; October 21, 2014
- ALJASSER: In Favor of InterVarsity - Virginia Cavalier Daily; October 23, 2014
- Discriminating and Dignifying: Faith-based Clubs Derecognized - Houghton Star; October 24, 2014
- Christian Faith Group No Longer Recognized by Campus - San Jose State Spartan Daily; October 26, 2014
- Open Membership Havoc - Mustang News Letter to the Editor; October 27, 2014
- Being Too Inclusive - Gustavian Weekly; November 6, 2014
- Defending Policy, Tradition, and Faith - CSU Northridge Sundial; November 26, 2014
- InterVarsity derecognized as student organization due to student leader requirements - CSU San Marcos Cougar Chronicle; December 23, 2014
- InterVarsity derecognized on campus - CSU-East Bay Pioneer; January 22, 2015
- Coalition formed in response to CSU policy - The Cal Poly Pomona Post; March 10, 2015
- Executive Order 1068 effects getting worse - Letter to the Sonoma State Star; April 27, 2015
MAGAZINES
- Campus Christian Groups Should be Allowed to Remain Christian - Mother Jones; June 10, 2014
- Will InterVarsity Losing Cal State Standoff be Tipping Point for Campus Ministries Nationwide? -
Christianity Today; September 8, 2014 - InterVarsity will "Reinvent" Student Ministry on California State University Campuses - Christianity Today; September 9, 2014
- California Colleges Remove Christian Ministry from 19 Campuses; World; September 9, 2014
- Student Christian Group Loses Official Status at Cal State - Chronicle of Higher Education; September 17, 2014
- What's Lost in Not Recognizing Campus Religious Groups - The Altantic/Karen Swallow Prior; September 21, 2014
- At California Universities, Christian Groups Face De-recognition - America; October 3, 2014
- Controversy Heats Up Over Exclusionary Religious Groups - Chronicle of Higher Education (subscription required), October 6, 2014
- The D-word is Coming to a Campus Near You - World; October 11, 2014
- Sent Packing - World on Campus; November 10, 2014
- Many Evangelicals Wary of Faith Requirements for Evangelical Groups - Christianity Today; May 6, 2015
- Denied and Derecognized - Inheritance; May 15, 2015
BROADCAST
- College campuses resemble closed countries - Mission Network News; September 4, 2014
- Greg Jao Interviewed on Fox and Friends; September 9, 2014
- Religious Exclusion and Illegal Discrimination - KCRW Public Radio;September 24, 2014
- California Diversity Law Excludes Christians, Could Harm Victims Rights Groups - FaithRadio; October 13, 2014
- Derecognition Not Bogging Down InterVarsity - K-Love Radio News; October 14, 2014
- Actualidad Semanal - Aliento Vision (Spanish Language); October 16, 2014
- Cal State No Longer Recognizes National Christian Group; Citing Anti-Bias Policy - CBS2/KCAL9; October 10, 2014
- Religious Freedom on Campus - Breakpoint This Week; November 21, 2014
BLOGS
- Commentary from an alumnus of Sonoma State University - Wordpress blog; August 11, 2014
- 5 Thoughts on the Cal State System Derecognizing InterVarsity - Patheos/Thoughtlife blog; September 5, 2014
- California "Derecognized" Christian Ministry for Requiring Leaders to be Christian - Campus Reform; September 8, 2014
- InterVarsity "Derecognized" at California State University's 23 Campuses: Some Analysis and Reflections -
The Exchange blog at Christianity Today; September 6, 2014 - The Best Evangelicals on Campus - Patheos/The Anxious Bench; September 11, 2014
- When Your Campus Ministry is 'Derecognized' - Desiring God; September 11, 2014
- College and University Administrators Demolishing Freedom of Religion and Association - Professor Stephen Bainbridge; September 19, 2014
- Does Religious Diversity Count? - Capital Commentary/Stephen Monsma; September 29, 2014
- Ratio Christi Kicked Off of San Jose State University Campus - RatioChristi blog; December 4, 2014
ONLINE PUBLICATIONS
- InterVarsity Christian Ministry in Trouble for Acting Christian - First Things; September 9, 2014
- InterVarsity Forced to "Reinvent" Campus Ministry Due to CSU Non-Discrimination Policy - Christian Post; September 10, 2014
- CSU Bans InterVarsity Christian Fellowship - University Herald; September 10, 2014
- Let's De-recognize Colleges that Discriminate Against Christians - Acton Institute; September 12, 2014
- The Perverse Effects of the "All Comers" Requirement - John Inazu, Library of Law and Liberty; September 15, 2014
- The Irony of California's Ousting of Campus Christian Groups - Townhall.com/Jerry Newcombe;
September 18, 2014 - Campus "Diversity" Puts Religion on Probation - BloombergView/Virginia Postrel; September 18, 2014
- Uphold Doctrine; Avoid Discrimination - First Things/Jeremy Erickson; September 19, 2014
- The Perversity of Diversity - The American Conservative/Rod Dreher; September 19, 2014
- The Campus Ministry Squeeze - tothesource.org; September 19, 2014
- InterVarsity and the Closing of the California Mind - Townhall.com/Travis Weber; September 21, 2014
- The InterVarsity Situation: Christian Unity in the Face of State Derecognition - MissioAlliance/James Tedford; September 22, 2014
- Challenged Universities: Can't Christians be Christian? -Iona Institute; September 23, 2014
- California Students Fight for Free Association with New Organization - The Torch/FIRE; October 6, 2014
- Campuses Keep Coming Up With More Reasons to Censor Christians - Christian Post/David French;
October 8, 2014 - Three Reasons Christian Students Will WIn - Alliance Defending Freedom; October 14, 2014
- Religious Freedom Under Attack - Rich Nathan; October 20, 2014
- San Diego State's President Talks a Good Game on Free Speech - But That's All -
The Campus Fix; October 30, 2014 - Standing Firm Amid Intolerance - The Triangle Tribune/Baptist Press; November 20, 2014
- Investigatively Reporting the Campus Access Story - GetReligion.org; November 25, 2014
- The Bible on Campus - Christian Post/Roy Peterson; December 2, 2014
- Christian Clubs Struggle - The College Fix; February 25, 2015
- Student Freedom of Association Act Debated in Sacramento - The College Fix; April 21, 2015
- Legislative committee rejects CSU all-comers policy change - The College Fix; April 24, 2015
- California Assembly Higher Ed Committee Rejects Student Religious Liberty Bill - Campus Reform; May 4, 2015
- How to Protect Your Faith-Based Business - Charisma/Liberty Institute; May 25, 2015
On September 9, 2014, InterVarsity issued a news release responding to the California State University system policy. In early October a new coalition was announced, dedicated to returning the Constitutional principle of free association to the California State University system campuses. On October 8, 2014, we published an article summarizing the first month's response to the new CSU enforcement. On June 19, 2015, we published a news release describing the resolution of the dispute.